The midterms were not a bad night for Trump | Cas Mudde | Opinion | The Guardian

Whether the Republican establishment likes it or not – and more and more are actually perfectly happy with it – the Grand Old Party is now Trump’s Party. Their fate is intertwined with his. The old conservative Republican party is dead, for now. In the coming two years they will campaign as a radical right party, led by an omnipresent leader, who will define the Republican party for a whole generation of Americans.

That’s from The Guardian, and it isn’t meant to take away from the many gains made on Tuesday night, which includes Republicans losing the House (providing at least some form of check to Trump’s power), and it also includes historical wins that break ground for greater diversity in representation, beyond the choke hold on power by aging straight white males.

However, Trump isn’t going away. The Tuesday election solidified that this is the party of Trump, with many explicitely pro-Trump politicians winning on the Trump platform. Trump didn’t lose, on Tuesday, which means that Nativism and Nationalism and verbal attacks on racial minorities and women and are all the new norm. In 2016 Trump brought the monsters out of the swamp, and they have found a home among the electorate that compose today’s Republican Party.

“The old conservative Republican party is dead.” Very true.

First Gay Governor - Colorado politics
Jared Polis, progressive Colorado politician — on Tuesday was the first openly gay man elected governor

This provides opportunities, of course, as the article mentions:

“Trump’s party will face a Democratic party whose diversity is both its strength and its weakness. It allows them to tap into a much broader electorate than the Republican party, but it also might prevent them from presenting a clear and coherent program. At the same time, most of the power is set to remain in the hands of the old white party elites, some of whom will also play a major role in the party primaries.”

For those who stand in resistance to The Party of Trump, the question has to do with the extent to which we can unify, while still retaining our diversity of perspective and opinion. Out of the many, one?

As a writer, this question has always intrigued me, perhaps more than any other in politics, because it’s a question of narrative. The MAGA narrative unites the Trump Right around a simple message: America has always been great, except when liberals interfere or when immigrants bring crime and disease or when American minority groups get upitty. MAGA is simply code for retaining traditional American privileges and prejudices, but it works to bring folk together, in a tribal way, to fight a common enemy.

MAGA is a story, and stories are powerful. Stories bring us together under a common narrative, allowing millions of strangers to cooperate and work toward common goals and objectives.

There is no such story for the anti-MAGA resistance. Whether this is good or bad, I suppose, is a matter of debate. Many people cringe at the idea of a simplified MAGA message: such seems to be the road to mindless forms of totalitarianism. That’s fair, but for my money I believe in the power of stories, whether simple or complex.

Nothing moves us like stories, and we live in an era where the stakes are high. We have to cooperate or suffer the consequences. The major problems that face humanity — ecological issues like climate change or geopolitical issues like nuclear war and immigration and resource distribution — all demand cooperation, of some sort.

How do we find the ability for this kind of mass cooperation? How can we cooperate without a common enemy, without having to evoke a scary “Other”?

Published by

Jonathan Erdman

Writer. In the summers, I live and work in the incredible state of Alaska, in the bush community of McCarthy, as the Executive Director of the Wrangell Mountain Center. When not in McCarthy, you'll typically find me in the Santa Cruz Mountains of California, writing and working with local activists. My primary writing project right now is a novel set in remote bush Alaska, of the magical realism genre wherein an earnest and independent young woman finds a mysterious radio belonging to her grandmother, a device that has paranormal bandwidth and a disturbing ability to mess with one's mental stability.

2 thoughts on “The midterms were not a bad night for Trump | Cas Mudde | Opinion | The Guardian”

  1. Ugh! It must be your gut issues making you depressing. I have to believe that there is always hope for the resistence. It all comes down to time and persistence. I think the resistence that women are displaying around the country (for 2 years running) is an integral part of the solution. The feminine is powerful and I think we have come to the place in time where a shift in awareness is going to make the Dalai lama’s statement that the Western woman will save the world, happen. It has commenced. It will leave the white woman behind if she doesn’t get her head out of the sand. People are going to wake up and realize what douch bags they are, whether it be because they actually “see” the results close to them of Trump’s antics, or his antics actually infringe on their civil liberties. And that will happen. Hopefully, we will still be alive and kicking to reap the benefit of our small part in the resistence. I strive to be full of hope. Sometimes it is difficult. The story is common decency. It is a story worth fighting for…no matter how long it takes, or how many forms it takes along the way. I realize that you know this and recognize that you live this.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, I’m with you. There were many encouraging things to come out of Tuesday’s election, and the increased participation of women, both in terms of running (and winning) political office as well as going to the polls, that was extremely uplifting for me as well. Common decency is worth fighting for. Thank you for this reminder, my friend.


Consider this post an invitation, an invitation to comment and collaborate ~ In Solidarity, JE

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.